CAPE MAY, NEW JERSEY SHOULD BE ON YOUR BUCKET
LIST
Published 7/19/25
As one who grew up in central New Jersey, I was embarrassed
at how little I knew about the southernmost community in the Garden State, Cape
May. I had passed through the area on several occasions., but never did a deep
dive into its many offerings. This all changed during the first week in June
when our three couples that normally take up residence in Chincoteague
Virginia, decided a change of scenery was in order.
Rather than search through Vrbo or Airbnb, we contacted a
local realtor specializing in Cape May rentals. We were rewarded with a
beautiful in-town renovated home with three bedrooms, all on one level. Parking
is a problem in Cape May and our rental came with off street parking to
accommodate the three vehicles. When parking elsewhere in the community, Cape
May uses a phone app that records the number of your parking space and accepts
payment.
It is helpful to know something of Cape May history to
understand the development of this beautiful beach town. According to
information published by the City of Cape May, as early as 1766 the location
became a resort destination for Philadelphia’s upper class and plantation
owners from the South. Stagecoaches, sloops and schooners brought those
escaping the heat, to stay in rustic public houses to enjoy sea-bathing and the
plentiful seafood.
In 1852, the Mt. Vernon, which was then the largest hotel in
the world, was built to accommodate 3500 guests. Unfortunately, this building
and other landmark hotels were destroyed by a beachfront fire. The Civil War
brought hard times to the Cape, when all the southern vacationers disappeared.
In the late 1860s, the completion of a railroad line from
Philadelphia to the Cape started the next surge of development, known as the
cottage era. Middle class families could now step off the train onto the beach
for the day. Others built modest cottages on small parcels of land. At the
close of the century, Cape May struggled to compete for wealthy patrons when
Newport, RI and Atlantic City became the more accessible go-to summer locations.
Two events put Cape May back on the map. First, in 1954 the
Garden State Parkway opened, making the isolated area more accessible by
automobile. Second, in 1963 Cape May received $3.5 million, the first large
urban renewal grant for a small city. Preservationists restored the many
beautiful Victorian homes that are now the hallmark of the town. Today, the
pedestrian Washington Street Mall and dozens of excellent restaurants make Cape
May a year-round destination.
Getting three couples to compare schedules and chose a week
away is always a challenge. Somehow, we were in luck with great weather and
interesting events taking place in Cape May. Our vacation was the designated
“restaurant week” that featured inexpensive prix fix dinners at many of the
better eateries. All of us consumed more gourmet desserts than we had planned.
We decided that the Cape May raw oysters were every bit as good as the famous Chincoteague
variety.
Our week was also the scheduled Cape May Music festival.
Vacationers looking for some excellent classical music could purchase tickets
for matinee and evening performances all over the city. Professionals from New
York City and New Jersey provided chamber music at churches and beautiful
outdoor settings.
Cape May beaches do not feature a boardwalk like its
northern neighbor, Wildwood. The beaches are wide, beautiful, have morning to late
afternoon lifeguards and require a daily or weekly pass. On each beach visit we
observed pods of jumping dolphins, just off shore.
What is missing in amusement rides, pizza joints and tee
shirt shops is more than made up with a long stretch of beautiful Victorian
homes and hotels, facing the ocean, with others located in the historical
district. Cape May is renowned for its
stunning variety of architectural styles and colorful facades. The big fire of
1878 destroyed much of the town. The city rebuilt itself quickly when the
Victorian era was in full swing. The preservationist movement has guaranteed
that these beautiful structures will be enjoyed by visitors for generations to
come.
One tourist activity I would recommend is a guided tour on
one of the many city trolleys that provide an introduction to the historical
district and surrounding area. Once the different types of architecture and
famous homes are explained, you can return for a more leisurely close-up view and
photo opportunities of these magnificent buildings.
I found that Cape May shopping, while geared for tourists,
is more upscale than many shore towns. There are more boutiques, book stores
and lobster roll establishments; less taffy and trinket shops.
The last but perhaps most famous Cape May attraction is its
conservation areas with world-renowned bird watching. The location and diverse
habitats (salt marshes, swamps, wet woods, fresh water marshes, ponds and pine
forest) are perfect for migrating birds. At the South Cape May Meadows nature
area, birders recorded over 75 species during the month of May.
Well-marked, flat walking trails make it mandatory to pack
your binoculars and camera with zoom lenses. For those interested in native
plants there are several botanical gardens. There are boat tours to view unique
birds like osprey, along with dolphins and humpback whales during the spring
and summer months.
Cape May offers a unique shore experience that vacationers
should add to their bucket-list.